Why Topping Up Is Risky
Kratky's rule for non-circulating hydroponics is that the solution level may stay the same or fall, but may not be raised, "or else the roots will drown". The roots that grew down into the moist air above the solution are adapted to air. Raising the level more than about 2 cm after that point may cause plant injury, according to Kratky's 2004 paper, and in his cucumber method he warns that adding water or fertilizer to the container may injure the plant.
The Better Answer: a Bigger Container
Kratky avoided top-ups entirely by giving each cucumber 100 to 130 liters. If your containers keep running low, the next crop needs a bigger one. See Kratky container size for cucumbers.
If a Container Runs Low Before Harvest
Kratky describes a way to grow long crops in small containers: let the level drop well below the pot, then hold it within a narrow band, about 3 cm, by adding solution or with a float valve. He calls it cumbersome, but it works. In practice:
- Mark the level on the outside of the container when you decide to start holding it.
- Add only what brings it back to that mark, never above it. Small, frequent additions keep the change within a few centimeters.
- Pour gently through a gap at the edge of the lid, or through a separate fill hole, without lifting the lid.
- Use solution, not plain water, at the same strength or slightly weaker. See Kratky nutrients for cucumbers.
When Not to Top Up
If the crop has had a good run and the plant is slowing down, it may simply be finished. Kratky ended his cucumber crops when less than 10 percent of the solution remained. Pick the remaining fruit and start fresh (see when to harvest Kratky cucumbers).
