From the blog
How Many Cucumbers Per Plant?
One well-grown Kratky vine can give you a few kilograms of cucumbers. Here are the real numbers from the method's inventor, and what pushes a vine above or below them.
How many cucumbers per plant you get depends on the variety, the weather, how often you pick and how long the solution lasts. The best guide comes from Dr. Kratky's own trials with one vine per container.
Kratky's numbers
- In his 2004 paper, yields exceeded 7 kg (about 15 lb) per 120-liter container in cool growing conditions.
- He adds that about half of that, around 3.5 kg (8 lb), is a more normal expectation.
- His home-garden instructions suggest aiming for about 5 lb (2.3 kg) per plant.
In fruit, that depends on the type. A small pickling or snack cucumber might weigh 100 g or less; a long English cucumber can weigh several times that. So 3.5 kg could be thirty-plus small cucumbers or a dozen long ones.
What raises the yield
- Cool, mild weather. Kratky's top yields came in cool conditions. The vine uses water more slowly, so the container carries it through a longer harvest. See the best temperature for growing cucumbers hydroponically.
- A big enough container. The crop ends when the solution runs out. A bigger container means a longer harvest: see Kratky container size for cucumbers.
- Picking often. University of Minnesota Extension notes overly large fruit lowers the plant's yield. Pick at a good size, every day or two at the peak.
- The right variety. Productive, disease-resistant, seedless types tend to give the most indoors: see the best cucumber varieties for Kratky.
- Good pollination for seeded types, so every female flower becomes a full-sized fruit.
What lowers it
- Hot weather, which empties the container sooner and reduces fruit set.
- Pests and disease. Kratky's instructions note the crop often ends after about a month of harvesting because insect or disease pressure builds.
- Too little light indoors.
- Leaving overgrown fruit on the vine: see overgrown cucumbers.
How many plants do you need?
Utah State University suggests 2 to 3 cucumber plants per person for fresh eating, plus a few more if you want to pickle. That is for garden plants; a well-grown Kratky vine is in the same range. For a steady supply rather than a glut, stagger them: succession planting cucumbers.
Is it worth it?
For one vine in a trash-can-sized container, with no pump, no power and no watering, a few kilograms of fresh cucumbers is a good return. And unlike a garden bed, the container can sit on a patio, porch or concrete. The Kratky method for cucumbers explains how it works.
Bush, slicing and long seedless types
The type of cucumber changes what a good harvest looks like:
- Bush types stay compact and suit smaller spaces, but usually give fewer fruit over a shorter period.
- Slicing types, picked at about 7 to 8 inches according to the University of Alaska Fairbanks, give a steady supply of medium fruit.
- Long seedless greenhouse types, picked at 12 to 24 inches, give fewer but much bigger fruit, and need no pollination.
- Pickling and snack types are picked small and often, so they give the most fruit by count.
Keep a simple harvest log
The best way to know your own yield is to weigh it. A kitchen scale and a note on your phone with the date and weight of each picking tells you:
- When your vine peaked, and how long it cropped.
- Whether a bigger container or a cooler season helped.
- Which variety did best in your space.
Write down the sowing date and the date the container ran low too. After one or two crops you'll know what your setup can do, which is worth more than any average.
Sources
- Kratky, B.A. (2004). A suspended pot, non-circulating hydroponic method. Acta Horticulturae 648, 83–89. University of Hawaii CTAHR.
- Kratky, B.A. The Wheel Garden (includes growing hydroponic cucumbers in a plastic storage container). University of Hawaii CTAHR.
- University of Minnesota Extension: Growing cucumbers in home gardens
- Utah State University Extension: How to grow cucumbers in your garden
Questions
How Many Cucumbers Per Plant: Questions
How many cucumbers does one Kratky plant produce?
Dr. Kratky got more than 7 kg per 120-liter container in cool weather, and says about half that is more typical. That's roughly 3 to 7 kg of fruit per vine.
How many cucumber plants do I need for a family?
Utah State University suggests 2 to 3 plants per person for fresh eating, plus a few extra for pickling.