From the blog
Overgrown Cucumbers: What to Do with Them
One missed cucumber hides behind a leaf for three days and comes out the size of a club. Here's why that matters to the whole vine, and what you can still do with it.
Overgrown cucumbers happen to everyone. Cucumbers grow fast once they get going: Utah State University notes fruit is ready about 5 to 7 days after the flower opens, so a few days away can leave giants on the vine.
What happens to an overgrown cucumber
- Tough skin and big seeds. Utah State says oversized fruit loses flavor and gets tough skin and mature seeds.
- Yellowing. Slicing types turn yellow as the seeds ripen. University of Minnesota Extension advises picking slicers before they get over-large with big seeds and yellowish skin.
- Bitterness, sometimes, especially on a stressed vine in hot weather. See bitter hydroponic cucumbers.
Why it matters to the vine
A cucumber left to ripen tells the plant it has done its job: it has made seeds. Minnesota Extension notes overly large fruit lowers the plant's yield, and the University of Alaska Fairbanks greenhouse guide says mature fruit left on the plant reduces production. On a Kratky vine, every day it spends filling a giant is water and nutrients not going into new fruit.
What to do with the big ones
- Pick it now. Even if you won't eat it, getting it off the vine is good for the next fruit.
- Taste a slice from the stem end. If it's mild, peel it and scoop out the seeds. The flesh is fine for salads, salsas, chilled soups, or grated into tzatziki.
- Pickle it as spears or relish, with the seeds scooped out: see quick refrigerator pickles.
- Bitter or yellow and spongy? Compost it.
- Save the seeds? Only from open-pollinated varieties. A fully ripe, yellow cucumber is exactly what seed savers want: see saving cucumber seeds.
How to stop it happening
- Pick every day or two at the peak of harvest.
- Know your variety's size. Alaska's guide picks slicing types at 7 to 8 inches and long seedless types at 12 to 24 inches. Check the seed packet.
- Look under the leaves. Train the vine up a trellis so fruit hangs where you can see it.
- Going away? Pick everything bigger than a finger before you go, even if it's small.
For full harvest timing by type, see when to harvest Kratky cucumbers.
Ideas for big cucumbers
- Chilled cucumber soup: peel, seed and blend with yogurt, garlic and herbs.
- Tzatziki or raita: grate, squeeze out the water, and stir into yogurt.
- Cucumber relish: finely chop, salt, drain and mix with vinegar and spices. Keep it in the fridge like refrigerator pickles.
- Infused water: thin slices in a jug of cold water.
- Salsa: diced, seeded cucumber works well with tomato, onion and chili.
Taste a slice first. Bitterness is concentrated near the stem end and in the skin, and peeling often removes most of it. If the flesh itself is bitter, it won't improve with cooking.
A Kratky-specific tip
Late in the crop, when the solution level is low, it's tempting to leave fruit to "finish" on the vine. Do the opposite. With less solution left, the vine is better off putting what it has into the next few cucumbers than into a single giant. Picking smaller and more often also makes it easier to see how fast the vine is still producing, which tells you when it's time to start the next container: succession planting cucumbers.
Sources
Questions
Overgrown Cucumbers What to Do with Them: Questions
Can you eat overgrown cucumbers?
Usually, yes. Peel them and scoop out the big seeds. If a slice tastes bitter, or the fruit is yellow and spongy, compost it.
Do overgrown cucumbers stop the plant producing?
They slow it down. A ripening fruit pulls the plant's energy into seeds, so picking promptly keeps new fruit coming.